Mariano Rivera took the hill in the ninth inning on Sunday, donning pinstripes on a sunny day in New York, looking to shut the door as he’s done so many times during his remarkable career. But this was not the Rivera the game of baseball is used to witnessing. The best closer–and one of the best pitchers–the sport has ever seen entered the series finale with the Detroit Tigers having blown two consecutive saves. He was staked a two-run lead, made possible in large part to a terrific running catch by Brett Gardner to rob Torii Hunter in the eighth, and was looking to keep from losing the lead in three straight outings. This is his 19th and final season, and that would’ve been a first.
That Gardner’s eighth-inning catch caught base-runner Austin Jackson napping and resulted in an inning-ending double-play, Tigers’ hitting savant Miguel Cabrera was forced to mosey from the on-deck circle back into the dugout. Had Jackson not thought Gardner dropped the ball upon crashing into the center-field wall, Cabrera would’ve been on base with a chance to tie the game. As it was, he still managed to make a resounding contribution. Two days after launching a tying two-run homer off Rivera, he crushed a 2-2 cutter over the right-field wall to pull Detroit within one. The pitch Rivera threw that fell amongst the fans wasn’t necessarily a mistake; it was a testament to just how good Cabrera is. A cutter two batters later to Victor Martinez, however, was unfortunately placed. Martinez scolded the offering into the second deck for a shocking tying blast. All Rivera could do was muster a frustration-filled, bewildered smile as the Tigers DH rounded the bases. It happened: a third straight blown save.